The Lobster Bar

The Lobster Bar is upstairs at 81 Pope Avenue, Unit 201, a short walk from Coligny Beach Park and Coligny's Pope Avenue shops. It serves lobster rolls, a chicken sandwich and cocktails in a dining room with big open windows. At the 2025 Hilton Head Wingfest it took second place with the judges.

The Lobster Bar Menu

What to Order at The Lobster Bar

Lobster rolls are the reason to come, and there are two styles: the Connecticut roll, warm lobster with butter and lemon on a toasted split-top bun, and the Maine roll, chilled lobster with mayonnaise and spices on the same bun. Reviewers call the lobster rolls delicious, and the chicken sandwich and the chicken tenders also get good mentions. Rolls come with a side, and a fries upcharge on some orders drew one complaint, so ask what comes with yours.

The Room and the Bar

The dining room is upstairs, and the open windows give it light and a view of the treetops. Reviewers like sitting by the window with a drink, and one stopped in right at opening just for cocktails. Service is described as friendly and attentive on most visits. Two reviewers on busy nights met a single server for the whole room, so allow extra time at peak hours.

Reservations and Hours

Book through the restaurant's OpenTable page or call (843) 715-0224. Check the current hours before you go.

Getting There

Pope Avenue runs from Coligny Circle toward the beach. The Lobster Bar shares 81 Pope Avenue with the New York City Pizza on the ground floor. For more fresh fish and shellfish, see the seafood restaurants guide, or browse every Hilton Head restaurant.

What diners say

The lobster rolls are the draw, and the chicken sandwich and the room, with its big open windows, get good mentions too. Servers are called attentive on quieter visits. On busy nights reviewers describe one server for the whole dining room, slow food and orders that came out incomplete, and some found the lobster rolls expensive for what was in them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Updated

Where is The Lobster Bar on Hilton Head?

Upstairs at 81 Pope Avenue, Unit 201, near Coligny Beach Park and Coligny Plaza.

What kinds of lobster roll does The Lobster Bar serve?

A Connecticut roll with warm lobster, butter and lemon, and a Maine roll with chilled lobster, mayonnaise and spices, both on a toasted split-top bun.

Does The Lobster Bar take reservations?

Yes. Book on its OpenTable page or call (843) 715-0224.

Is The Lobster Bar downstairs or upstairs?

Upstairs, in Unit 201. New York City Pizza is on the ground floor of the same address.

Is there a view at The Lobster Bar?

The dining room has large open windows with a view over the trees. It is not on the water.

Your beach week starts here

Compare villa and beach home prices from local rental companies side by side, and catch last-minute deals before they’re gone.

Search vacation rentals

Property manager? Partner with us