Where Do the Locals Eat in Hilton Head?

Harold's Diner, a low brick building with the red Harold's Diner sign and an American flag out front

Ask people who live here where they eat and the answers are rarely the biggest names on the water.

Seafood locals recommend

4.6 ★ (3.3K)· $$

Counter-service seafood off Pope Avenue: fried, grilled or blackened, on paper plates, with a line in summer. Locals have eaten here for decades.

One of the island's oldest seafood restaurants, on the water at Skull Creek.

4.7 ★ (1K)· $$$$

A cottage French bistro with a daily handwritten menu built around the day's fish.

4.4 ★ (2.4K)· $$

Shrimp and grits on a brick patio that feels like a backyard cookout.

Casual local hangouts

4.5 ★ (4.7K)· $$

A loud, family-friendly barbecue place with a shaded patio, known for wings, brisket and ribs.

4.5 ★ (1.2K)· $$

A deck over the marsh at Broad Creek Marina, famous for the Creek burger.

Thin-crust pizza in a room that is a shrine to Ohio State.

A small taproom that calls itself the island's first brewery, with a shady patio.

Breakfast locals swear by

4.5 ★ (1.3K)

A cash-only counter diner with big breakfasts, burgers and plenty of attitude.

A diner open for more than 30 years, serving breakfast all day.

4.4 ★ (303)· $$$$

A family-run brunch spot with beignets and pancakes.

About this list

They are counter-service seafood, a cash-only diner, a barbecue patio and a French bistro that has been full for years. These are the places island residents send visitors to first.

The list below is grouped by what you are in the mood for. If you want more, the full restaurant directory covers every venue with its own page.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where do the locals eat in Hilton Head?

Island residents point to the Sea Shack and Hudson's for seafood, Charlie's L'Etoile Verte for a special night, One Hot Mama's for barbecue and Harold's Diner for breakfast.

Where do locals eat seafood in Hilton Head?

The Sea Shack, Hudson's Seafood House on the Docks and A Lowcountry Backyard come up most. Charlie's L'Etoile Verte writes its menu daily around the fresh catch.

What are the best local restaurants for breakfast?

Harold's Diner, Hilton Head Diner and Sea Grass Grille are the breakfast favorites on this list.

Are these restaurants touristy?

They are the places residents recommend to friends and family, and most are casual counter-service or neighborhood spots rather than resort restaurants.

Local guides like this come standard for Guests of Partner Properties — one small part of what a Partner Property gives every guest.

Book Partner Properties