Best Pizza on Hilton Head Island, SC
Pizza on Hilton Head runs the whole range, from wood-fired pies to New York slices and Chicago-style pan pizza.
Best pizza places on Hilton Head Island
Wood-fired pizza, garlic knots and craft beer with a daily happy hour; calls itself the Lowcountry’s first wood-fired pizza.
Thin-crust pizza in an Ohio State-themed room; guests who eat gluten-free praise the gluten-free pie.
A thin-crust pizza place with a big local following and homemade chicken tenders and garlic knots.
Family-owned since December 2013, with handcrafted pizza, wings, garlic knots and chopped salads.
New York-style slices and pies, heroes and a full bar at Festival Centre and on Pope Avenue by Coligny; open since 1996.
Flatbread pizzas and bang bang shrimp on a covered porch near Coligny, with a 4 to 6 happy hour.
Hand-tossed, charred-crust pizzas at The Triangle, a food complex where three restaurants share one kitchen.
Chicago-style pan pizza and Italian beef, opened in 2026 across from Coligny Plaza; open 3 to 9, Monday to Saturday.
Pizza delivery on Hilton Head
Several of these restaurants deliver. Delivery zones are small on an island this spread out, so check that the shop covers your address before you order.
Dine-in, take-out and online ordering, with delivery through GrubHub.
About this list
Pizza on Hilton Head runs the whole range: wood-fired pies, thin-crust pizza in a sports-themed room, New York slices (NY pizza by the slice at New York City Pizza), Chicago-style pan pizza and a new pizza counter in a food-truck-style complex. Nearly every neighborhood has a pizza place, and several also have a full bar and a happy hour.
This is our guide to the best pizza on the island. A good rule for a vacation week: pick the pizza place nearest to your rental, and ask whether it delivers.
More ways to choose where to eat
Italian restaurants Hilton Head Island: chef-owned dinners, family red-sauce rooms and pizza and pasta counters, with phone numbers and booking notes.
Kid friendly restaurants Hilton Head Island: playgrounds, lawn games, kids menus, game rooms and early-bird dinners for a family vacation.
Sports bars Hilton Head South Carolina: where to watch the game, from Ohio State and Chicago bars to a resort screen wall, with phone numbers.
Food delivery and takeout on Hilton Head Island: restaurants that deliver, takeout-only spots, late-night kitchens and how to order to a rental.
Every pizza place on the island in one list, with ratings, phone numbers and how to reserve.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizza on Hilton Head Island?
Local Pie is the wood-fired pizza place, Mangiamo’s and Fat Baby’s are the thin-crust favorites, and New York City Pizza and Bella Italia serve New York-style pies. Reviews and locals split on the winner, so the best choice is often the one closest to your rental.
Which Hilton Head pizza places deliver?
Dough Boys Pizza delivers with its own drivers, Mangiamo’s delivers through GrubHub, and New York City Pizza and Bella Italia both do delivery.
Is there gluten-free pizza on Hilton Head?
Mangiamo’s has a gluten-free pizza guests praise, and Bella Italia has 10-inch gluten-free and cauliflower crusts.
Where can I watch a game and eat pizza?
Mangiamo’s is an Ohio State-themed room with big screens, and New York City Pizza has a full bar and televisions.
Your beach week starts here
Compare villa and beach home prices from local rental companies side by side, and catch last-minute deals before they’re gone.
Property manager? Partner with us