Pembroke Drive
New York City Pizza, Festival Centre
The location this page describes, next to the Publix in Festival Centre.
- 45 Pembroke Dr #105, Hilton Head Island, SC 29926
- (843) 689-2229
New York City Pizza
$$
Hours
Monday11 AM–9 PM
Tuesday11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday11 AM–9 PM
Thursday11 AM–9 PM
Friday11 AM–9 PM
Saturday11 AM–9 PM
Sunday11 AM–9 PM
Phone
(843) 689-2229Reservations
Walk-ins onlyWhere it is
Get directionsNew York City Pizza is in the Festival Centre shopping center at 45 Pembroke Drive, next to the Publix, and it has been selling New York-style pizza on Hilton Head since 1996. The dining room is bright red with televisions and a full bar, and there is outdoor seating with cornhole boards.
New York City Pizza Menu
New York City Pizza is open for lunch and dinner. The menu centers on pizza, with moderate prices.
What to Order at New York City Pizza
Start with the pizza: big folded slices by the plate or whole pies, from a plain cheese to the NYCP Special and a white pie. Reviewers who grew up on the Jersey Shore and in New York call the sauce and cheese right and the crust crisp, and one suggests asking for the bottom well done if you want it blistered. Beyond pizza there are wings, house-made meatballs, spaghetti and meatballs, salads, a Philly cheesesteak and a chicken parmigiana hero. The restaurant says its ingredients are all natural. Use the menu button above for the current menu.
Dine In, Take Out and Order Online
It is a seat-yourself pizzeria and does not take reservations, so parties just walk in. You can also order online for pickup or delivery, which many locals do, and a slice at the bar is a quick lunch. Service gets warm reviews from most guests, though a single visitor left after a long wait for a server on a quiet night.
Getting There
The restaurant is at 45 Pembroke Drive, Suite 105, in Festival Centre at the northern end of Pembroke Drive on Hilton Head Island. More places to eat are on the Hilton Head restaurants page, and the Hilton Head dining guide sorts them by meal and style.
Across the bridge, New York City Pizza has two more restaurants, in Belfair Towne Village and at Buckwalter Place; see New York City Pizza Bluffton.
Two New York City Pizza Locations
New York City Pizza has two restaurants on Hilton Head Island: the original in Festival Centre on Pembroke Drive, and a second on Pope Avenue by Coligny. Each has its own phone number and its own Google rating.
Coligny
New York City Pizza, Pope Avenue
On the ground floor at 81 Pope Avenue, a short walk from Coligny Beach Park, below The Lobster Bar.
- 81 Pope Ave A, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928
- (843) 842-2227
What diners say
Visitors from New York, New Jersey and beyond praise the pizza: well-seasoned sauce, quality mozzarella and a crisp crust in the New York style, plus a good Philly cheesesteak and large salads. The staff and manager get warm mentions, the dining room and bar are clean and welcoming, and there is outdoor seating with cornhole.
Frequently Asked Questions
Updated
Does New York City Pizza take reservations?
It is a walk-in restaurant. Seat yourself, or order online for pickup or delivery.
Where is New York City Pizza on Hilton Head?
At 45 Pembroke Drive, Suite 105, in the Festival Centre shopping center next to the Publix.
Does New York City Pizza sell slices?
Yes. You can order pizza by the slice as well as whole pies.
What else is on the menu besides pizza?
Wings, meatballs, spaghetti, salads, a Philly cheesesteak, chicken parmigiana heroes and a full bar.
Is there a New York City Pizza near Coligny Beach?
Yes. The second location is at 81 Pope Avenue, Unit A, a short walk from Coligny Beach Park. Its phone is (843) 842-2227.
What are the hours at New York City Pizza?
Every day, 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Call (843) 689-2229 to check holiday and off-season hours.
Your beach week starts here
Compare villa and beach home prices from local rental companies side by side, and catch last-minute deals before they’re gone.
Property manager? Partner with us