Michael Anthony’s Cucina Italiana is at 37 New Orleans Road in Orleans Plaza, and it is the island’s dressy Italian dinner. The dining room has white tablecloths and warm walls, and the kitchen makes its pasta and desserts fresh every day. It has been around for more than two decades, and the restaurant describes itself as sophisticated but approachable. Most people come for an anniversary or a night out, though the room is comfortable rather than stuffy.

What to Order at Michael Anthony’s

Fresh-made pasta is the draw. Reviewers keep naming the lasagna, the clam linguine, veal and seafood dishes, and the tiramisu, and profiteroles with smoked salmon turned up as a fun starter. Servers get praised for wine and dish suggestions, such as a splash of balsamic on the lasagna, and one reviewer had a gluten-free entrée built for her. The menu button above opens the dinner menu.

Reservations and the Market Cafe

The restaurant strongly recommends reserving, and you can book online through OpenTable or by phone at (843) 785-6272. Parties of more than six need to call. Dinner runs Monday to Saturday from 5 p.m. and the restaurant is closed on Sunday. For something more casual, the sister Market Cafe next door does lunch, happy hour and dinner, and sells pasta, sauces and Italian pantry goods to take home. The restaurant also runs cooking classes.

Getting There

Michael Anthony’s is at 37 New Orleans Road, Hilton Head Island. More places to eat are on the Hilton Head restaurants page, and the Hilton Head dining guide sorts them by meal and style.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Michael Anthony’s take reservations?

Yes, and the restaurant strongly recommends them. Book online through OpenTable or call (843) 785-6272. Parties larger than six need to call.

What days is Michael Anthony’s open?

Dinner is served Monday to Saturday from 5 p.m. The restaurant is closed on Sunday.

Is Michael Anthony’s a casual restaurant?

The dining room is dressy and romantic, and it is popular for anniversaries. The sister Market Cafe is the casual option, with lunch, happy hour and dinner.

What is Michael Anthony’s known for?

Fresh pasta made in house, lasagna, veal and seafood dishes and tiramisu, along with attentive service and wine recommendations.

Local guides like this come standard for Guests of Partner Properties — one small part of what a Partner Property gives every guest.

Book Partner Properties