Earle of Sandwich Pub
Hours
Where it is
Get directionsThe Earle of Sandwich Pub has served sandwiches and beer in Coligny Plaza since 1973. It is a casual pub with a quirky, lived-in interior and a patio outside, and it is open Monday to Saturday from 11:30 a.m., with the kitchen serving until 9 p.m. and the bar open later. It is closed on Sundays. Despite the name it has nothing to do with the Earl of Sandwich chain.
Earle of Sandwich Pub Menu
Earle of Sandwich Pub is open for lunch and dinner. The menu centers on pub food, with moderate prices.
What to Order
The Reuben is the sandwich reviewers rave about, and the house sandwiches, the Earle and the Duke, have their own fans. The soups are homemade, and there are burgers, a French dip and a crab cake sandwich. Prices are fair for a resort area and the portions are big. Most reviewers find the staff friendly, though a few have had off days with service.
The pub is at 1 N Forest Beach Drive, I-4, and it is walk-in only. For other places nearby, see the Coligny Plaza restaurants.
What diners say
Reviewers praise the sandwiches, especially the Reuben, the Earle and the Duke, as well as the burgers and the homemade soups. They like the friendly staff, the reasonable prices and the casual feel. The criticism that recurs is staff behaviour, which some reviewers found unprofessional.
Frequently Asked Questions
Updated
Is the Earle of Sandwich Pub open on Sundays?
No. It is open Monday to Saturday.
What is the Earle of Sandwich Pub known for?
Its Reuben, the house sandwiches called the Earle and the Duke, and homemade soups.
Is the Earle of Sandwich Pub related to the Earl of Sandwich chain?
No. It is an independent pub that has been in Coligny Plaza since 1973.
Your beach week starts here
Compare villa and beach home prices from local rental companies side by side, and catch last-minute deals before they’re gone.
Property manager? Partner with us