Frosty’s Ice Cream, Hilton Head
Hours
Where it is
Get directionsFrosty’s Ice Cream is a family-owned ice cream shop on the harbour side of Shelter Cove, at 9 Harbourside Lane, Suite F on Hilton Head Island, in the row of shops around the marina basin. It is the after-dinner stop for the harbour’s restaurants, and on summer evenings the line can run out the door. You will often see it written Frostys Ice Cream, without the apostrophe; it is the same shop.
Frosty's Ice Cream Menu
The menu centers on bakery and café fare, with low prices.
What to Order at Frosty’s
There is scooped ice cream in a long list of flavors, from the classics to some oddly named house ones, plus Italian ice, Hershey’s chocolate and vanilla soft serve, sundaes (banana splits, brownie and cookie sundaes) and milkshakes. The shop lists no-sugar-added and dairy-free choices, and reviewers say the staff take allergies seriously and let you sample before you choose. Portions are generous, so a kid-size cone goes a long way.
Where Frosty’s Is
Frosty’s is open daily. It sits among the harbour shops at Shelter Cove Harbour & Marina, a short walk from the restaurants on the basin, and Shelter Cove restaurants lists every place to eat on both sides of the district. It is not the same place as the Frosty Frog Cafe at Coligny Plaza.
What diners say
Visitors praise rich ice cream in a wide range of unusual flavors, with Italian ice and dairy-free choices too, and portions that are generous. The staff come up in review after review as friendly and patient, even with a line out the door on summer nights.
Frequently Asked Questions
Updated
Where is Frosty’s Ice Cream on Hilton Head?
At Shelter Cove Harbour, 9 Harbourside Lane, Suite F, among the shops around the marina.
Does Frosty’s have dairy-free or no-sugar-added ice cream?
Yes. The shop lists no-sugar-added and dairy-free options; ask at the counter what is in the case that day.
Does Frosty’s serve soft serve and Italian ice?
Yes. Alongside scooped ice cream it serves Hershey’s soft serve, Italian ice, sundaes and milkshakes.
Is Frosty’s the same as Frosty Frog?
No. Frosty’s Ice Cream is at Shelter Cove Harbour; the Frosty Frog Cafe is a separate restaurant at Coligny Plaza.
What are the hours at Frosty's Ice Cream?
Every day, 11 a.m. to 9:30 p.m. Call (843) 715-0064 to check holiday and off-season hours.
Your beach week starts here
Compare villa and beach home prices from local rental companies side by side, and catch last-minute deals before they’re gone.
Property manager? Partner with us